Old Country Bumpkin, Master Swordsman II PV Introduces Shuste, Alushia's Rival
『片田舎のおっさん、剣聖になるⅡ』PV第四弾でシュステ登場、アリューシアとの三角関係に日本のファン反応

The official Japanese anime channel for From Old Country Bumpkin to Master Swordsman II dropped its fourth promotional video mid-season, and the headline reveal is a new character, Shuste, whose introduction reads immediately as a rivalry with Alushia Citrus for Beryl's attention. The PV also carries over the emotional payoff from the training arc that just wrapped — Beryl beating his father in a duel, followed by his mother's words — while previewing bigger, movie-scale action still to come.
Across 212 comments, most of the excitement lands on Shuste's arrival and the love-triangle framing, but the thread's most substantive exchange is actually a source-material debate: a reply chain works through how faithful the anime is to the original light novel versus the separately-drawn manga adaptation, with one commenter arguing the anime has already overtaken the manga's story progress entirely.
By the end, one reply about the show's 45-year-old lead landing a love interest in her mid-20s gets the thread's most agreeable answer yet.
The official Japanese channel for From Old Country Bumpkin to Master Swordsman II posted its fourth promotional video mid-broadcast, and the headline is a new character: Shuste, whose first appearance is framed as a rival to Alushia Citrus for Beryl's attention. Most mid-season PVs for this show have just been recaps with a couple of new frames spliced in, so a genuinely new character showing up here is enough on its own to reset the comment section's whole mood. The PV also loops back to the emotional high point of the training arc that just aired — Beryl finally beating his father in a duel, followed by his mother's words — while teasing bigger, more movie-scale fights still ahead for the back half of the season.
The top-liked comment on the whole video isn't from a novel reader working out what any of it means — it's from someone going in completely blind, and reacting to the pace of it all the same way plenty of the thread does.
“Whoa?! As someone who hasn't read the source material, my honest reaction is "what is this?!" It's getting more interesting by the minute!”
おおおお! 原作未読としては、なんじゃこりゃですよ。ますます面白くなりますな!
Most of the section's energy goes straight to Shuste's debut, and it's read almost unanimously the same way: a new love rival just walked in, and the show is finally going to let the middle-aged lead have a proper romantic subplot instead of just fending off admirers from the sidelines.
The PV also gives fans a beat to look back on before it looks forward — the fight where Beryl finally beats his own father, and what came right after it. It's a callback rather than new footage, but the section treats it less like recycled material and more like a chance to revisit a scene they'd already decided was the emotional peak of the season so far.
There's also plain hype over the production scale, but the section's actual disagreement shows up somewhere else entirely: a reply chain about whether new viewers should even bother with the manga adaptation.
“Honestly, this scale would work as a movie.”
このスケール感は劇場版でもええなぁって思う。
“You shouldn't bother with the source manga. It's basically a different story at this point.”
原作コミックは見ない方がいいです。もう別物です。
“The manga was never really the source material to begin with, so that commenter's not wrong. If you treat the original novel as canon, the anime trims it down into a cleaner, more polished version — though it loses some of the original's rawness, which some people would actually call part of its charm. The manga, working from that same canon, is more like an exaggerated retelling — the kind a bard would sing about, dialed way up for effect. That's fun in its own right, and I think it works for plenty of people.”
@yoshifmadoka4543 漫画版はそもそも原作ではないし、特にコメ主は間違っていないよ。 原作小説を正史とするならアニメ版はそれをかいつまんで内容を綺麗に整えた感じ。ただ元の生々しさや人に依っては「雑味」と呼ぶ「良さ」もそれなりに削れている。 漫画版は正史を元に、例えば吟遊詩人が面白おかしく誇張して歌ったような、かなり大袈裟な内容と言える。それはそれで面白いし大勢にはウケるとは思うけどね。
“The anime's already overtaken the manga's story progress at this point anyway, so reading it wouldn't really change anything for you.”
@yoshifmadoka4543 そもそもアニメはストーリー展開でコミカライズを追い越しちゃってるから、見たところで影響は無いね。
The debate settles itself more than anyone resolves it. What actually closes out the thread has nothing to do with canon at all — just one honest question about a 45-year-old lead landing a love interest in her mid-20s, on top of a brand-new one in Shuste.
“Wasn't the "old country bumpkin" like 45? And Alushia's what, mid-20s? Lucky old man.”
片田舎のおっさんって確か45歳位でしたっけ、 アリューシアは20代半ばくらい? 羨ましいなおっさん
“He's just got a genuinely cool way of living, honestly. If you're that cool, age doesn't really matter.”
普通に生き様がかっこいいからね。かっこよければ年齢関係ないと思う。
Nobody in the section actually disagrees with that — not about the age gap, not about the new rival, not even about which version of the story counts as "real." Two hundred and twelve comments into a mid-season PV, the thread's only real consensus is that Beryl earned all of it, love triangle included.
FAQ
- What does the PV 4 for From Old Country Bumpkin to Master Swordsman II reveal?
- The official channel's fourth promotional video, posted mid-broadcast, introduces a new character named Shuste and frames her as a rival to Alushia Citrus for Beryl's affection. It also revisits the emotional beat of Beryl defeating his father in a duel and previews larger-scale action for upcoming episodes. It drew 212 comments.
- What did Japanese fans react to most?
- Shuste's debut and the implied love triangle with Alushia got the most immediate reactions, with several comments calling the rivalry a highlight to watch for. A separate thread also debated how closely the anime follows the original light novel compared to its manga adaptation.
- Was there any disagreement in the comments?
- The closest thing to a real debate is over the source material: one commenter warned viewers away from the manga adaptation, calling it "basically a different story," while another pushed back that the manga was never meant to be canon in the first place and explained how the novel, anime, and manga each handle the same events differently — with a third adding that the anime has already passed the manga's story progress entirely.
From Old Country Bumpkin to Master Swordsman Cast Gets Tipsy — What Japan Said
“Hirata's probably just an amazing host, isn't he”
Read this roundupThis is one of 4 Japanese-reaction roundups for From Old Country Bumpkin to Master Swordsman. See them all →
More from Japan
- From Old Country Bumpkin to Master Swordsman
1,099 likesAnimeYouTubeFrom Old Country Bumpkin to Master Swordsman Season 2 Episode 1 — Japan on the Unicorn OP
On the free-viewing upload of Season Two's premiere, Japanese fans left 356 comments — and the top-liked reply, with 1,099 likes, wasn't about swordplay at all: it asked whether everyone else watching was also a middle-aged guy. The recurring theme was self-aware fandom: viewers traded ages in the replies, then lit up again when the opening theme turned out to be sung by veteran rocker Okuda Tamio's band Unicorn. A smaller thread argued gently over manga purists versus anime-only viewers, while one commenter said the episode's teaching arc hit close to home now that they're training their own sword students in real life. By the end, the joke had come full circle — a show about a middle-aged swordsman, watched by fans happy to admit exactly who they are.
356 comments - #Japanese Fans
1,858 likesAnimeYouTubeMushoku Tensei Clip Rounds Up Nanahoshi's Three Headaches with Rudeus — What Japan Said
A Japanese fan channel cut together three separate Mushoku Tensei III moments that all revolve around the same joke: Rudeus keeps dumping his problems on Nanahoshi, the fellow Japan-born isekai transplant, whether it's a doll-making project gone strange, a blunt question about her weight, or advice for his family drama. The 201-comment section split its attention almost evenly between the doll bit and the weight question, with the top comment (1,858 likes) pointing out the doll was never meant to be a "love doll" in the first place — it just ended up that way from trying to make something too human-like. From there, fans debated whether Rudeus was being genuinely insensitive by asking if she'd gained weight, or whether it doubled as him checking on her health. By the end, more than one commenter had landed on the same pun: the real "heavy" thing here wasn't the conversation Nanahoshi kept getting roped into. It was her.
201 comments - #Japanese Fans
5,002 likesAnimeYouTubeChainsmoker Cat Manga Clip: Yuta's Freak Healing Power Steals the Whole Thread
A Japanese manga-narration channel posted a Chainsmoker Cat clip titled "the two monsters Shizue produced are just too much," built around the chain-smoking side character Shizue and two chaotic characters tied to her. Across the clip's 517 comments, though, the runaway topic isn't Shizue or her smoking habit — it's a side character named Yuta. The top comment (5,002 likes) is actually about the smoking angle, but the second-highest (4,733 likes) is a one-line reaction to Yuta, and from there the thread spends most of its energy comparing his self-healing body to Black Jack and to the parasite-possession manga Parasyte, debating which of the two "monsters" is really the scarier one. It closes with a few commenters stepping back to treat the whole clip as a case study in what kind of parenting produces a monster.
517 comments - ColumnAnime
Why Japanese Anime Keeps Winning: What Japan's Own Comment Sections Give Away
Ask why Japanese anime is so hard to beat and the answer usually comes back as a pile of nouns. Budgets. Sakuga. I spend my nights reading and translating Japanese comment sections, a few thousand at a time, and from that side of the glass the answer sits much further upstream. Not in the show you streamed. In everything that got cut before it ever reached you. That part never shows up on a timeline.