Rankings
What Japanese fans actually talk about
We took the 5320 Japanese comments we have translated across 298 articles and sorted them by what they were about. This is not a like-count leaderboard: it ranks titles by how much of their comment section went to a given topic.
Bar length = the share of that title’s comment section. Updated every Monday (JST). The quote under each rank rotates weekly.
Titles Japan praised the craft of
The thickest topic in Japanese comment sections: animation, direction, soundtrack, voice acting. How often a comment went to how the thing was made.
- 01
Jaadugar: A Witch in Mongolia1 in 5 comments21% · 18/86 · 6 articles@かりん柚木26 likes Draw This, Then Die! is the best, right? You cry at Kokoro's bravery, and then in the second half the teacher's absolutely devastating crying scene makes it hard to breathe 🎉 This season there are so many shows I absolutely can't drop that a top five isn't enough. What a lovely summer 🌺
これ描いて死ねは、こころちゃんの勇気に涙した後に後編での先生のとんでもねぇ泣き方に息が苦しくなったりと最高ですよね🎉 今季は覇権作絶対に切れないのが沢山あるので5位までじゃないと足らないくらい素敵な夏です🌺
Read the article this comment is from - 02
The Ghost in the Shell1 in 6 comments18% · 13/74 · 5 articles@sei-un1,500 likes This is the part where we're supposed to be moved that Shirow Masamune's actual artwork is moving...
士郎正宗の絵が動いてて感動してるトコなんだから…
Read the article this comment is from - 03
Dragon Ball1 in 6 comments18% · 24/137 · 12 articles@女々し86 likes Wait, did King Kai's voice actor change at some point? I was impressed there was barely any difference in how he sounded.
界王様の声優って変わったんだっけ? 声の違和感少なくてすごいなぁって思ったんだけど
Read the article this comment is from - 04
The 100 Girlfriends Who Really, Really, Really, Really, Really Love You1 in 7 comments14% · 6/42 · 3 articles - 05
Sakamoto Days1 in 8 comments13% · 8/60 · 2 articles - 06
JoJo's Bizarre Adventure1 in 8 comments13% · 13/101 · 9 articles - 07
The Elusive Samurai1 in 10 comments10% · 7/69 · 4 articles - 08
The Apothecary Diaries1 in 11 comments9% · 9/95 · 7 articles - 09
Re:Zero1 in 14 comments7% · 14/196 · 15 articles - 10
Mushoku Tensei1 in 18 comments6% · 21/373 · 28 articles
Titles that gave Japan chills
The record of being floored — 鳥肌 (goosebumps), 神回 (a god-tier episode), and the rest of the vocabulary Japanese fans reach for when a scene lands.
- 01
Jaadugar: A Witch in Mongolia1 in 11 comments9% · 8/86 · 6 articles@ジムダステギ-v3r10 likes In Jaadugar, the moment in episode 3 where her face settles into that fully-resolved smile mid-conversation with Shira gave me chills. It felt like standing in the room for the moment a girl became the witch who would later throw Mongolia into chaos.
ジャードゥーガルは3話のシラとの会話の最中覚悟ガンギマリの笑顔になるところでゾクッとした 1人の少女が後にモンゴルを動乱に陥れる魔女になった瞬間に立ち会った気持ち
Read the article this comment is from - 02
Sakamoto Days1 in 12 comments8% · 5/60 · 2 articles@しらっしー14 likes My hype is through the roof!! I'm already way too excited for it to air...!! Shin's so good. I love Kanaglo... Yotsumura's so cool.
めっちゃテンション上がってきた!! 今から放送が楽しみすぎてヤバいぜ…!! 周いいなぁ 神々廻さん好きぃ… 四ツ村さんかっこよ
Read the article this comment is from - 03
Bleach1 in 20 comments5% · 16/321 · 27 articles@Tubaki316152 likes Thinking about it again, this is a Bankai that basically guarantees a kill on contact. That's genuinely terrifying.
よく考えたらこれ卍解当たったらほぼ死にますって性能だからマジでやばいんよなw
Read the article this comment is from - 04
Gundam1 in 21 comments5% · 6/128 · 4 articles - 05
Re:Zero1 in 22 comments5% · 9/196 · 15 articles - 06
Mushoku Tensei1 in 22 comments5% · 17/373 · 28 articles - 07
One Piece1 in 43 comments2% · 16/694 · 43 articles - 08
Chainsmoker Cat1 in 44 comments2% · 9/393 · 29 articles
Titles Japan laughed hardest at
Comments reporting an actual laugh — 爆笑, 草 (Japan’s version of "lol"), and the like.
- 01
Honkai: Star Rail1 in 4 comments25% · 16/64 · 2 articles@Rikkun25.2033,426 likes "I wonder how many it killed" is so heartless I'm dying.
「何キルしたんだろうなぁー」は人の心無さすぎて死ぬ
Read the article this comment is from - 02
Meccha Chameleon1 in 5 comments18% · 9/49 · 3 articles@こうちゃ-v8p-l6o2,041 likes It's not that HE stops — he's making the OTHER guy stop. I'm dying lol
自分がSTOPするんじゃなくて 相手をSTOPさせてるのマジ草
Read the article this comment is from - 03
Chainsmoker Cat1 in 9 comments11% · 44/393 · 29 articles@ぬぬぬーぬぬぬぬ464 likes Chainsmoker Cat was already bad enough, but Junkie Cat is basically unairable, lmao.
ヤニねこでも十分やばいのにヤクねこはもう放送禁止レベルで草生える
Read the article this comment is from - 04
The Elusive Samurai1 in 10 comments10% · 7/69 · 4 articles - 05
JoJo's Bizarre Adventure1 in 13 comments8% · 8/101 · 9 articles - 06
Blue Lock1 in 13 comments8% · 6/80 · 4 articles - 07
One Piece1 in 16 comments6% · 43/694 · 43 articles - 08
Jujutsu Kaisen1 in 17 comments6% · 8/139 · 5 articles - 09
Bleach1 in 19 comments5% · 17/321 · 27 articles - 10
Re:Zero1 in 25 comments4% · 8/196 · 15 articles
How this is counted
The pool is the 298 articles currently published on our English side and the 5320 Japanese comments we excerpted and translated inside them. Nothing is pulled in just for the tally — every comment counted is one you can read in an article.
For each title we only count comments from articles about that title (articles that merely mention it in a comparison do not count). Titles with fewer than 40 comments, or fewer than 5 matches, are left out, so a rank is never decided by a two-comment gap.
Classification is a keyword pass run over both the Japanese original and the English translation, so 「作画がすごい」 and "the animation is insane" count as the same thing. It misses some comments, but everything it counts really does say the word. The headline "1 in N" is just the matches-over-pool ratio rounded, and every row shows the raw counts it came from. No weighting, no adjustment.
We also keep axes for tears, fear, and long-awaited returns, but there are still too few matching comments for those ranks to mean anything, so they are not published yet. They go up once the pool grows.