AnimeYouTube
One Piece SBS: Oda's Flight-Fruit Answer Backfires on Fans
尾田先生のSBS回答が炎上、ファンからの質問に逆ギレと話題に
Source: YouTube11 of 245 comments translatedOriginal text alongsideJapan Reacts editors
One Piece creator Eiichiro Oda answered a reader's question in the manga's SBS Q&A column about which flight-granting Devil Fruits the character Pell knows about — and instead of naming them, he replied that Pell doesn't know about every flight-type fruit in existence, dodging the actual question. On a Japanese reaction video collecting comments on the exchange, readers are calling the answer defensive and evasive rather than funny.
Across 245 comments, the most-liked one (217 likes) jokes that a reply this touchy over a simple question must mean something's up. Others go further: one highly liked comment (123 likes) says Oda seems to have mistaken ordinary criticism for an attack, while another with 84 likes breaks down exactly why the answer doesn't logically respond to what was asked in the first place.
Not every comment is pure mockery, though — some end up somewhere more wistful, comparing this answer to how playfully Oda used to handle SBS questions in the manga's earlier years.
In the latest volume's SBS Q&A column, a reader asked One Piece creator Eiichiro Oda which flight-granting Devil Fruits the character Pell specifically knows about, pointing to an in-story encyclopedia Pell had seen during the God Valley arc. Instead of naming them, Oda replied that Pell doesn't know about every flight-type Devil Fruit in existence — technically true, but not actually an answer to what was asked. On a Japanese reaction video collecting comments on the exchange, readers spent far more time picking apart the answer than the question itself.
The SBS column has run in the manga's collected volumes for decades as a lighthearted space where Oda fields reader questions directly, and it's built a reputation for playful, often joke-filled answers rather than defensive ones. That history is exactly why this particular exchange stood out to readers: a straightforward request for specifics got met with something that reads less like an answer and more like a deflection, and the comment section noticed immediately.
Why would a simple question hit this hard? I bet this is important!!
なんでただ質問しただけなのに効いてるんだ? 多分コレ重要な事だ!
The fact that he bothered addressing it in the SBS column at all tells you it must have really gotten under his skin.
わざわざSBSで取り上げる辺りよっぽど腹に据えかねたんだろうな。
He's probably been criticized so much that he mistook this for an attack too — it was just a question asking him to name the five types he had in mind at the time.
批判されすぎてこれも攻撃だと勘違いしちゃったんだろうな、その時考えてた5種を教えてって質問に過ぎないのに。
The author got irritated instead of properly answering the question — honestly, maybe it's time to just end the SBS Q&A corner.
質問者の質問に、きちんと答えずキレてる作者もうSBSの質問コーナーやめた方がいいと思う
Beyond the general sense that the reply felt touchy, commenters started laying out exactly why it doesn't hold up as a response. The thread's most detailed comment goes line by line to show that the question and the answer aren't even talking about the same thing — the reader never asked whether Pell knows every flight-type fruit that exists, only which ones he happens to know.
1:32, this is exactly it... The question was "Which flight-granting Devil Fruits does Pell know about?" and the answer was "Pell doesn't know about every flight-granting Devil Fruit out there." That's clearly not answering the question. "Pell doesn't know about every one" doesn't address anything — the whole point of asking "which ones does Pell know about" was that nobody was assuming he knew all of them...
1:32 まさにこれなんですよね…… 「ペルが知っている飛行能力を持つ悪魔の実とはどれのことですか?」という質問の答えが「ペルが飛行能力を持つ悪魔の実を全て知っているわけではありません」は明らかに会話として成立していないんですよ。 「ペルが飛行能力を持つ悪魔の実を全て知っているわけではありません」も何も『だから「ペルが知ってる飛行能力を持つ悪魔の実とはどれのことですか?」と質問している』わけで……
Couldn't he have just said, "Here are the five flight-type fruits listed in the encyclopedia Pell saw"? Problem solved.
「ペルが見た図鑑に載っている飛行能力の5種はこれです」と言えばすむ話では?
From there the comment section splits into two very different reactions. One side takes it all the way to wanting the series ended outright, framing a single evasive answer as a symptom of something bigger. The other side pulls back and gets nostalgic instead, comparing the moment to how playfully Oda — and manga creators in general — used to handle these exact kinds of nitpicky reader questions.
I want it cancelled right now. Because I love One Piece.
今すぐ打ち切りにして欲しい ワンピースが好きだから
I love how, back when Dragon Ball's Toriyama accidentally drew Great Demon King Piccolo with the wrong number of fingers, he just wrote it off in-story as Piccolo's fingers having grown a fifth one.
ピッコロ大魔王の指(4本)の本数を間違えたときは指が5本に増えちゃったと書いていた所大好き❤
It's kind of bittersweet remembering when the SBS column had that vibe... "Bird-Bird Fruit, Gas-Gas Fruit, this one, that one, and finally the Potato-Potato Fruit — eat a potato and fly on fart propulsion! You'll drop after five seconds," complete with a goofy drawing of some guy actually flying on farts... "What even is this," and it'd end on a warm, silly note like that.
昔はそういうノリだったなぁ…となんか切なくなった トリトリの実、ガスガスの実、あとアレとソレと、最後がイモイモの実のおいも人間、イモを食べて屁の推進力で空を飛びます!5秒で落ちます って感じでオチつけて、実際に屁で飛ぶアホな顔のオッサンが描かれて… 何じゃそら、とちょっとホッコリして終わる感じだったな
That's the note the thread actually settles on — not outrage, but a kind of quiet nostalgia for a version of the SBS column that could turn a silly, half-baked question into something charming instead of something to brace for. Nobody in the comments thinks a single terse answer means much on its own, but enough readers recognized the same tone shift independently that it became the real story of the exchange, more than whatever Pell actually saw in that encyclopedia.
One Piece Episode 1180: Anime Staff Quietly Rewrite More of Oda's Clunky Lines
"The manga's iron-clad grammar" — I genuinely love this one.
Read this roundupFAQ
- What did the reader actually ask Oda?
- According to commenters, a reader asked which flight-granting Devil Fruits the character Pell specifically knows about, referencing an in-story encyclopedia Pell had seen.
- Why do commenters say the answer doesn't make sense?
- One highly liked comment (84 likes) points out that Oda's reply — "Pell doesn't know about every flight-type Devil Fruit" — restates something nobody was asking about, since the question was specifically which ones Pell does know, not whether he knows all of them.
- Are all the comments negative about it?
- Not entirely — one comment recalls how Toriyama once playfully wrote off a Dragon Ball drawing error in-story, and another wistfully describes Oda's own older, more playful SBS answers, framing the new reply as a shift in tone rather than pure mockery.
This is one of 43 Japanese-reaction roundups for One Piece. See them all
More from Japan
- One Piece

AnimeYouTube
One Piece Anime Smooths Out One of Its Most Notoriously Clunky Lines
This week's One Piece anime finally adapted one of the manga's most notoriously clunky exchanges — and while animating it, staff quietly rewrote the dialogue around it, though not the meme phrase itself. On a Japanese reaction video collecting comments on the episode, the edit itself became the whole conversation before anyone got to the actual story. Across 461 comments, the top comment (996 likes) points out that the anime left the manga's actual meme line untouched and only smoothed out the dialogue immediately around it. Not everyone is as forgiving: another highly liked comment (532 likes) argues that needing the fix at all is something Shueisha's editors should be embarrassed about. From there the thread splits between blaming the source material and crediting the anime staff's editing, and commenters can't stop previewing next week's episode, which apparently crams several more of the manga's most-memed exclamations into just a few pages. By the end, even the skeptics admit they're curious to hear a professional voice actor deliver the next one out loud.
461 comments
- #Japan Reacts

AnimeYouTube
Mushoku Tensei Season 3 Episode 14: Finale's Ending Line Breaks Japan's Heart
Mushoku Tensei Season 3 closed its 14-episode cour on September 27 with "Resolve," the finale where Rudeus commits to fighting Orstead and the episode ends on Eris sprinting off with "I'm coming now, Rudeus!!" right as Mika Nakajima's ending theme kicks in. On a Japanese recap channel that spends each week explaining what the anime trims from the original novels, the finale pulled in 419 comments, and that exact transition is the moment everyone keeps replaying. The thread splits almost evenly over everything else: one highly liked comment (454 likes) wishes the anime had kept a taunting line from the villain Hitogami intact, while another argues the trimmed dialogue makes Rudeus's decision to fight Orstead look like he agreed to it too casually. Plenty of other commenters push back, insisting the cuts were the right call for the episode's pacing — and anime-only viewers are already bracing for a long wait with no idea what happens next. By the end, the complaints mostly give way to people just replaying that final scene one more time.
419 comments
- #Japan Reacts

AnimeYouTube
Summer 2026 Anime Fan Poll: Jaadugar Wins No. 1, Record Votes
A Japanese anime review channel's season-ending fan poll for Summer 2026 has crowned Jaadugar: A Witch in Mongolia the season's top show, with Draw This, Then Die! taking second and Though I Am an Inept Villainess placing third. The vote drew over 600 participants, the channel's largest turnout ever, and the comment section spent far more time reacting to the results than arguing with them. Across 269 comments, several viewers who initially doubted Jaadugar because of its art style say they came around after actually watching it, and one comment even notes that the show's own creator showed up to react to the results. The discussion also digs into what made the rest of the top five stand out, from Draw This, Then Die!'s scrappy charm to Though I Am an Inept Villainess's small on-screen touches for foreign viewers trying to keep character names straight. By the end, even commenters who disagreed with parts of the ranking admit it was one of the deepest seasons in recent memory.
269 comments
ColumnAnimer/anime(朝日新聞の鈴木敏夫インタビューをAUTOMATON WESTが英訳した記事のスレッド)
Ghibli's Producer Waited Out the Ghibli-Style AI Trend. What Slop Sounds Like in Japanese.
Studio Ghibli producer Toshio Suzuki turned down every interview request during the Ghibli-style AI image boom, because he figured people would get bored of it on their own. He said so in an interview with Asahi Shimbun, AUTOMATON WEST put it into English, and it landed on r/anime. I opened that thread expecting a fight, since I read these comment sections every night for a living. Almost nobody was fighting. Here is what that thread actually said, what happens to the word slop when I carry it into Japanese, and why the Miyazaki line about an insult to life itself keeps getting attached to the wrong thing.