Japan Reacts

AnimeYouTube

Suikoden: The Anime Draws a Harsh Backlash From the Original Game's Fans

幻想水滸伝アニメ、原作ゲームのファンから厳しい批判が相次ぐ

Source: YouTube12 of 119 comments translatedOriginal text alongsideJapan Reacts editors

JapanSuikoden: The AnimeGenso SuikodenKONAMI
YouTube · アニメがっかりちゃんねる

Suikoden: The Anime is several episodes into adapting Suikoden II, KONAMI's 1998 RPG, and the reaction from people who actually played the games has turned sharply negative -- not because it was rushed into existence, but because it's getting basic things about the source material wrong.

Across the 119 comments on a Japanese anime-criticism channel's Amazon-review roundup, the most-liked complaints (up to 39 likes) come from longtime players rather than casual viewers: the anime skips the original Suikoden and adapts II directly, and characters keep acting out of nowhere just because the plot needs them somewhere else.

By the end of the thread, one comment sums up the whole situation better than any of the criticism does.

Suikoden: The Anime is several episodes into adapting Suikoden II, KONAMI's 1998 RPG, and the reaction from people who actually played the games has turned sharply negative. A roundup of Amazon reviews and comment sections singles it out as the fall season's biggest disappointment among original fans -- not for being rushed into existence, but for getting basic things about the source material wrong.

@みっぽ-l6i39 likes
As someone who's actually played the games, this is just way too bad... I was so looking forward to it. It's sad.

幻想水滸伝はゲームをやってる身からするとあまりにもダメすぎて…あんなに楽しみにしてたのに。悲しい😢

That's the throughline across almost every comment: this isn't outsiders dunking on an anime they never cared about. It's longtime players who waited years for this and are now watching it happen badly, which makes the disappointment land harder than ordinary adaptation complaints.

@藤原珠里奈25 likes
I played the Suikoden games as they came out in real time. I was happy to see it get an anime. Now all I'm left with is despair.

リアルタイムで幻想水滸伝シリーズをプレイしてきた。アニメ化は嬉しかった。今は絶望しか残らなかった。

Part of the anger is structural. The anime adapts Suikoden II directly, skipping the original Suikoden entirely, and several commenters say that's close to unforgivable on its own, since the sequel's stakes depend on knowing what happened in the first game.

@milacleyan17 likes
Suikoden II only works because of Suikoden I, and they just started from the sequel? You can tell it's being made by people with no love for the source material. The original creator's passed away, so I guess they can do whatever they want now.

幻想水滸伝は1があってこその2なのに 続編から始めるとか、原作愛がない人たちが嫌々作ってるのが見れる 原作者亡くなってるからやりたい放題なんだろう

The other recurring complaint is characters acting out of nowhere just because the plot needs them somewhere else -- behavior that reads fine as game pacing, where a cutscene can skip past motivation, but falls apart once it's dramatized on screen and has to hold up as writing.

@股関節痛む25 likes
In Suikoden, the characters only act the way the plot needs them to, so the unnaturalness is constant and I can't stop picking at it. It's a bad-writing problem. Dialogue that works because it's a game doesn't automatically work once you put it straight into an anime.

幻想水滸伝、話の展開が制作側の都合でキャラが行動してるために不自然さが前面に出ちゃってツッコミが止まらないんだよね。脚本が悪いパターン。ゲームだから許される脚本をそのままアニメにしたら駄目なパターンか。

@風見雄二-u7k35 likes
The characters' behavior in Suikoden is so broken at this point that I'm just watching it as a comedy.

幻想水滸伝はキャラの行動がおかし過ぎてギャグアニメとして観てる

Not every comment is pure venom, either. Several acknowledge Suikoden II's scope was always going to be brutal to compress -- it's a sprawling war epic with over a hundred recruitable characters -- and more than one commenter doubts even four cours could do it justice, let alone two.

@meeaam43687 likes
I always thought adapting Suikoden was going to be hard in the first place. If they actually tried to stay faithful to the source material, even four cours wouldn't be enough.

幻想水滸伝はアニメ化自体が元々難しいと思ってはいた。 本気で原作に忠実にしようとしたら4クールあっても足りないと思う。

Where the thread actually splits is over whose fault that is. One camp blames the studio for spreading itself across two new shows at once right out of the gate, with limited staff and barely two years of existence behind it; another argues Suikoden was always the harder, less commercial project to adapt, no matter how the studio allocated its time.

@山紀-y8s5 likes
KONAMI's animation studio only started up in 2024, so trying to make two shows at once right from the start was never going to work. A normal production takes one to two years just for one show -- the resources just aren't there. Still, when you're handling someone else's property, I think it's the right call to sacrifice your own IP first. It's a shame the hope that Suikoden's anime would spread the game's popularity didn't come true.

KONAMIのアニメスタジオって2024立ち上げだから初っ端から2作品作るのは無理があったんだと思う 普通作画のアニメ1作作るのに1年から2年かかるし、リソースが足りてない でも、自社コンテンツの幻水を犠牲にして他社の作品を優先してるのは作品を預かる立場としては正解だと思う 幻水アニメを機会に幻水SPが広まればという願いは叶わなかったのは残念

@ましろ_otsukyo10 likes
Is Suikoden bad because they put too much into Nia Liston? No -- if you don't already care about the Suikoden games, you're not watching this anyway.

二アリストンに力を入れすぎて、幻想水滸伝が駄作? いや幻想水滸伝のゲーム自体興味がないと視聴者はみない

@anime_gakkari4 likes
Honestly, Suikoden feels like the harder one to adapt, more than Nia Liston.

ニアリストンより幻水の方がアニメ化が困難に感じられますしね

@キャッパ-f5v0 likes
Suikoden I and II are my favorite RPGs out of everything I've ever played, which is exactly why I didn't want it getting an anime with voice acting at this point -- so I never watched it. Reading these comments, I'm convinced skipping it was the right call. Please stop dragging old games and anime back out just to turn them into disappointments.

幻想水滸伝1・2はやってきた全てのRPGの中で1番好きなゲームなので今更声優付けてアニメ化して欲しく無かったから全く視聴して無かったんですが見なくて正解だったとコメント見て思いました。過去のアニメやゲームを今更引っ張り出して駄作にするの本当にやめて欲しい

That last comment is basically the thread's verdict in miniature: the person who loves the games most is the one who refused to watch at all, and nothing in this thread is talking them into changing their mind.

Read next · #Japan

Dandadan Chapter 252 Reveals Okarun's Brutal, Lonely Childhood

This is way too hellish... Seriously, how did Okarun even make it through high school enduring all that…

Read this roundup

FAQ

What are Japanese fans criticizing about Suikoden: The Anime?
The two biggest complaints are that the anime skips the original Suikoden game and adapts Suikoden II on its own, and that characters frequently act in ways that only make sense for plot convenience rather than as believable behavior once dramatized.
Do commenters think Suikoden II was always hard to adapt?
Several do -- commenters note Suikoden II is a sprawling war story with over a hundred recruitable characters, and some doubt even four cours could fully do it justice, let alone the two the anime has.
Is the criticism aimed at the studio's resources?
Partly. Some commenters point out the studio producing Suikoden only started in 2024 and is also making another show, Nia Liston, at the same time, which they say spreads the staff too thin; others argue Suikoden was simply always the tougher property to adapt regardless of staffing.

More from Japan