Japan Reacts

AnimeYouTube

Steel Ball Run Episode 8: A Beer-to-Wine Swap Splits Fans

『スティール・ボール・ラン』第8話、ビールがワインに変更され原作勢で論争

Source: YouTube12 of 238 comments translatedOriginal text alongsideJapan Reacts editors

ジョニィ…まだ回転ならしてるぜ|アニメ『スティール・ボール・ラン』第8話 クリップ(公式)YouTube · Warner Bros. Japan Anime

Steel Ball Run's eighth episode swaps out a small manga beat -- the fugitive President chugging a can of beer and shouting "Yes! Yes!" -- for a quiet glass of wine instead, dropping the catchphrase entirely.

Across 238 comments on a Japanese reaction-compilation video built around manga readers noticing the change, the swap splits into two competing theories: the top comment (1,110 likes) reads the wine as deliberate Christian symbolism foreshadowing the series' holy-corpse mystery, while other highly-liked comments point to a flatter explanation -- aluminum beer cans don't fit Steel Ball Run's frontier-era setting. A few commenters just miss the original line.

Either way, nobody's claiming the President himself came out of the edit any leaner.

This titleJapanese reactions to JoJo's Bizarre AdventureRead all 9 roundups on the title page

Steel Ball Run's eighth episode trims a small, specific gag from the manga: in the source material, the fugitive President (Funny Valentine) chugs a can of beer mid-scene and shouts "Yes! Yes!" In the anime, that becomes a quiet glass of wine, with the catchphrase cut entirely. It's a one-panel beat in the manga, easy to miss unless you already know it's coming, but a Japanese reaction-compilation channel built its entire episode-eight recap video around manga readers noticing the swap, and the comment section underneath splits almost immediately over whether it's a clever fix or a straight-up loss.

The top comment doesn't treat it as a cut at all -- it reads the wine as a deliberate upgrade tied to the series' larger mystery, and the reply underneath tries to extend the same logic a step further, building out a small theory of its own from the one-line observation.

@DTCM-yz7pm1,110 likes
Wine carries the meaning of "the blood of Christ" in Christianity, so this might actually be a good change on its own terms. I think the anime is hinting even harder than the manga at what the holy corpse really is.

ワインというのはキリスト教では「イエス・キリストの血」という意味もあるから、これはこれで良改変かな。おそらくアニメの方は原作以上に聖なる遺体の正体をほのめかしまくるのかと思う。

@ヌメモン-r9s70 likes
If the President's chasing the corpse for religious reasons, this could've been a smart change.

大統領が宗教的な理由で遺体を追ってるなら良改変だったかもな

Just as many commenters skip the symbolism altogether and land on something flatter: Steel Ball Run is set at the tail end of the American frontier era, decades before aluminum beer cans existed, and a canned-beer close-up would've been the kind of detail that jumps out at anyone who knows the timeline.

@カンカンt2703 likes
Oh, they actually matched it to the time period. Makes sense.

ちゃんと時代に合わせてたんや、なるほどね

@ミミッキュ-w2w501 likes
Guess canned beer doesn't add up at the tail end of the frontier era.

開拓時代末期にアルミにビールは辻褄が合わなかったか

@週末ゾラ171 likes
It doesn't fit the era, and it's also a serious scene... I guess the manga's version was more like, "this got too dark, let's throw in a little gag as a breather"?

時代に合わないってのと真面目なシーンだからね… 原作は(暗すぎたからちょっとギャグ(小休憩)挟むか…)ってのなんかな…?

@バエル厨14 likes
Having him shotgun a beer in the middle of that particular mood and pacing would've been awkward anyway, and if historical accuracy is part of the reasoning too, I think it's a fine call.

アニメのあの雰囲気と流れでビールのショットガン飲みされても困るし、時代考証も含まれてるのなら良いかなぁ

That reading cuts both ways, though. It's still a parallel world full of its own science-fiction excesses, so not every commenter is convinced the show owes beer cans strict historical accuracy in the first place.

@tende710410 likes
Part of me thinks it's a parallel world, so canned beer could've just been invented early -- but another part respects the choice because the animation was so good.

パラレルワールドなんやから缶ビールくらい早めに発明されてても良いやんという思いと めっちゃ作画良かったから敬意を表する思いと2つある

@ghuhggg5519 likes
But it's already a different world, and there's a guy running around with actual mad science in it -- the whole argument's kind of pointless.

でも別世界やん。それにシュトロハイムがおる時点で無駄だろ

@ろくさす-v7o1 likes
It's a parallel world, so I don't think it'd feel out of place even if the timeline for when cans were invented were off. What I actually want to know is whether Araki himself signed off on this -- the original creator's approval should outrank everything else.

パラレルワールドなんだし別に缶が出来た時代がズレててもまったく違和感なんて無いのになぁ。 荒木先生が納得しているのか、いないのか気になる。 原作者の納得は全てに優先されるべきだからね。

Not everyone's ready to let the original gag go, either, catchphrase and all.

@ちくわ咲いている14 likes
I did want to see the "Yes! Yes!" line, but if canned beer's off the table, I guess it's off the table.

イエス!イエス!はみたかったけど 缶ビールダメならダメか。

@ダラボッチ3 likes
The game actually had a voice line for "Yes! Yes!", so it's a little disappointing, but I guess it can't be helped.

ゲームだとイエスッ!イエスッ!って声あったから少し残念だけどまあしょうがない

@朝倉友情141 likes
His gut, though? That part didn't get cut.

ただ脂肪は削られなかった模様。

Add it all up and the episode walks away with a full spread of theories: the wine lines up with the era, the symbolism checks out for at least one reading, and there's a small memorial thread for the beer can and its catchphrase that didn't make it. Whatever the adaptation trimmed in the name of historical accuracy, commenters agree on one thing -- it stopped short of trimming anything off the President himself.

Read next · JoJo's Bizarre Adventure

Steel Ball Run Stand PV: Japanese Fans Turn Tusk's Name Into a Running Joke

0:47 -- no matter how many times I rewatch it, "Listen to My Rhythm" hits just as hard.

Read this roundup

FAQ

What did Steel Ball Run's anime change from the manga in episode 8?
In the manga, the fugitive President chugs a can of beer and shouts "Yes! Yes!" In the anime, that becomes a glass of wine with no catchphrase at all.
Why do Japanese fans think the anime made this change?
Comments split between two explanations. The top comment (1,110 likes) reads the wine as intentional symbolism tied to the series' holy-corpse mystery, since wine carries a "blood of Christ" meaning in Christianity. Other highly-liked comments argue it's simpler than that: Steel Ball Run is set at the tail end of the American frontier era, before aluminum beer cans existed.
Did any fans want the original beer scene kept?
Yes -- some commenters say they wanted to see the manga's "Yes! Yes!" line animated, and one points out the line even had its own voice clip in a Steel Ball Run video game, which makes losing it in the anime feel like more of a loss.

This is one of 9 Japanese-reaction roundups for JoJo's Bizarre Adventure. See them all

More from Japan