Japan Reacts
AnimeJapan Reacts editorsYouTube

Re:Zero Break Time Episode 78: A Bodyguard Took Elsa's Arm — What Japan Said

リゼロ ミニアニメ第78話「裏稼業姉妹暗躍日報」、日本のファンの反応

Re:Zero Break Time Episode 78: A Bodyguard Took Elsa's Arm — What Japan Said

Re:Zero's official Break Time short for Episode 78, 「裏稼業姉妹暗躍日報」, went up the same night Season 4's second cour premiered, and it shows an early Elsa-and-Meili job where a bodyguard cuts off Elsa's arm — which then grows back while she tells Meili one arm is a cheap price for her sister being safe. Across 290 comments, Japanese viewers spent far less time on the sisters than on the man who managed it: the loudest recurring line is some version of "anyone who can take Elsa's arm has to be seriously strong," followed by a wave of One Piece jokes about Elsa out-Shanks-ing Shanks. The one real disagreement is how strong that bodyguard actually was, and it gets settled with a quote from the author. Under that runs a quieter thread about the box Elsa is carrying, and about Elsa being someone the main story can't show anymore. Two of the three highest-liked comments on the video are not analysis at all — one is a life decision, and the other is the reply that lands it.

This titleJapanese reactions to Re:ZeroRead all 8 roundups on the title page
Break Time mini-anime, Episode 78 (official) YouTube · 「Re:ゼロから始める異世界生活」チャンネル【公式】

Re:Zero Season 4's second cour opened in Japan on August 12, and the same night the official Japanese channel put up the Break Time short for Episode 78, 「裏稼業姉妹暗躍日報」 — a look back at one of the jobs Elsa and Meili pulled together, back when Meili was still new to the work. The short has a bodyguard take Elsa's arm off. She shrugs it off, tells Meili the arm was cheap next to her sister being safe, and the arm simply grows back. That's the whole thing, and it sent the Japanese comment section somewhere nobody planned for.

"Nooo!! Elsa!! Your arm!!" "It’s a cheap price, just one arm… I’m glad my little sister is safe." The fact that the arm then just regrows, boing boing, right after that exchange has to be a bug.

「だって…!! エルザ...!! 腕が!!!」 「安いものよ 腕の一本くらい…妹が無事でよかった」 この流れで本当に腕がニョキニョキ治るのバグだろ

@依空伊吹330 likes

Because the part everyone latched onto wasn't the sisters. It was the guy who managed to do that to Elsa in the first place, and he barely gets any screen time. Across 290 comments, the single loudest thread is people quietly doing the power-scaling math.

  • Cutting off Elsa’s arm? That guy has to be seriously strong.👍293
  • Whoever takes Elsa’s arm off is pretty damn strong, no?👍148
  • Severing Elsa’s arm — calling that bodyguard “skilled” doesn’t even cover it…👍66

And then, inevitably, One Piece showed up. Losing an arm to protect someone younger is a very specific image in Japan, and the jokes wrote themselves — except Elsa's arm grows back, which the comments decided makes her the upgrade.

Elsa: "I played paper." (with the left arm she grew back) ↑ A straight upgrade over Shanks.

エルザ「私はパーを出したわ(生やした左腕)」 ↑ シャンクスの上位互換

@筒隠月子-y6j67 likes
  • It’s Shanks, except a monster…👍113
  • So what you’re saying is "Shanks < Elsa"…👍25

Where it actually splits is how strong that bodyguard really was. One camp says nobody below Wilhelm-tier could pull it off. The reply is where it gets interesting, because it argues from what the author has said outside the anime.

You’d have to be on Wilhelm’s level to manage that.

ヴィルヘルム相当じゃないと無理だろうね

@yme326428 likes
That’s going too far. The author has stated outright that Wilhelm beats Elsa. He was probably only a bit stronger than Rem at most. And since this is a past scene, Elsa may not have been as strong then as she is now.

@yme3264 それは言い過ぎ ヴィルヘルムならエルザに勝てると作者が明言してる せいぜいレムより多少強いくらいだろ 過去の場面だから、エルザが今ほどに強くなかった可能性もあるし

@大河原博徳-m3n8 likes

The other thread running under all of it is the box. Elsa is carrying something in the short, and Japanese viewers who read ahead in the light novels are treating it as a possible plant rather than set dressing.

Isn’t this actually kind of important??? I don’t know where Subaru is in the timeline here, but if that box Elsa is carrying holds a Witch Factor, that’s a hell of a setup.

これ結構重要じゃないか??? 話で言うとスバルがどこ辺りか分からないけど、エルザが持ってる箱魔女因子ならめっちゃ伏線だよな

@帆楼-v8t39 likes

And then there's the part that's just affection. Elsa died two seasons ago; Meili is the one currently at the center of the main story. New material with the two of them together isn't something anyone expected to get in Season 4.

  • Genuinely grateful that we’re still getting new Elsa content in Season 4.👍20
  • Meili and Elsa’s stock has been skyrocketing lately.👍15
  • You can never have too many entries in the shady-sisters series.👍202

None of that is what pulled the biggest numbers, though. Two of the three highest-liked comments on the video are this one and the reply under it.

From now on I’m going to live my life modeled on Elsa.

これからエルザを参考に生きていきます

@ともス_sukirutensei270 likes
Just don’t let killing become a habit.

殺人が癖にならないようにな

@たこ焼きたこ焼き-p3q64 likes

Elsa's catchphrase in Japanese is 「癖になる」 — roughly "it becomes a habit," the line she purrs while gutting people. Which is why one of the most-liked comments on a short about a severed arm is somebody typing 「メ ィ リ ィ は 癖 に な る」, one full-width space between every character, about a little girl. Japan spent the night of the cour premiere power-scaling a nameless bodyguard and adopting an assassin. Next episode is in a week.

FAQ

What happens in the Re:Zero Break Time short for Episode 78?
It shows an early job Elsa and Meili worked together. A bodyguard cuts off Elsa's arm, she tells Meili it is a cheap price for her sister being safe, and the arm regenerates — the detail Japanese commenters kept calling a bug.
Why are Japanese fans comparing Elsa to Shanks?
Because losing an arm while protecting someone younger is a One Piece image in Japan. Commenters ran with it and concluded Elsa is the upgraded version, since her arm grows back — "Shanks < Elsa."
How strong was the bodyguard who cut Elsa’s arm off?
Commenters disagree. One says only a Wilhelm-tier fighter could do it; the reply argues that goes too far, citing the author stating Wilhelm beats Elsa, and adds that Elsa may have been weaker in this earlier scene.
Read next · Re:Zero

Re:Zero Cour 2 PV: The Two-Month Wait Ends August 12 — Japan Replies in Petelgeuse's Voice

I've been waiting for Dakkan-hen for real! I'm so hyped my brain is... trembling 🫨

Read this roundup

This is one of 8 Japanese-reaction roundups for Re:Zero. See them all

More from Japan