Japan Reacts

AnimeYouTube

THE ONE PIECE Netflix Remake Teaser Sparks Backlash: 'Finish the Manga First'

「まず原作を完結させろ」— THE ONE PIECEリメイク発表に日本の原作勢が激怒

Source: YouTube14 of 506 comments translatedOriginal text alongsideJapan Reacts editors

YouTube · 【驚愕】アニメ漫画クラブ

When THE ONE PIECE — the Netflix-backed remake of the original One Piece anime — dropped its teaser in June 2026, Japan's manga fanbase erupted across the 506 comments under the reaction video. The top comment, with 441 likes, called it 'a remake of a manga that's literally mid-meltdown and still unfinished.' The dominant fear wasn't the remake itself but that Oda would use it to retroactively insert Nika-related foreshadowing into the East Blue arc — one commenter predicted new shots like 'flashing a glimpse of Shanks' Abyss arm' getting quietly slipped in. A second flash point was the aging voice cast: veteran Tanaka Mayumi (Luffy's VA, now 71) reportedly turned it down once before accepting, and fans were furious she was being asked to restart a 1,000-plus episode journey. The sardonic close: 'Can you even call it a remake if the original isn't finished? ...Honestly, in a way, it already is.'

This titleJapanese reactions to One PieceRead all 43 roundups on the title page

THE ONE PIECE — the Netflix-backed remake of the original anime — dropped its teaser in June 2026, and Japan's manga fanbase did not take it well. Out of 506 comments under the reaction video breaking down the backlash, the top-liked one sets the tone for basically everything under it, and almost nobody in the thread is talking about the animation quality itself.

@赤福-s6e441 likes
A remake of a manga that's literally mid-meltdown and still unfinished — what are they even thinking?

今絶賛迷走中の未完漫画のリメイクってなんやねんマジで

The math is simple: the manga is still running, still mid-arc, and by most accounts still finding its footing. A remake of the beginning, while the ending is nowhere in sight, strikes a lot of readers as premature at best.

But the backlash isn't really about the remake existing. It's about what Oda might quietly slip into it — specifically, retroactive foreshadowing for Luffy's Sun God Nika powers, planted into a story arc that was written years before that reveal existed.

@ナイン2234 likes
What I hate is they'll probably shoehorn in all the Nika stuff.

多分リメイクにニカ関連ありそうで嫌なんだよね

@とことこ-w7v200 likes
They will 100% insert Nika and Zaza partway through, then say 'this is actually what I always meant to tell.' Absolutely guaranteed.

リメイク途中にニカやザザねじ込んで、「実は本当に描きたかったのはこういう事だったんですよ」をやるよな、確実に

Some commenters get specific about what that tampering might actually look like on screen.

@啓太佐藤-e3k151 likes
They're obviously doing this to retroactively patch the current plot holes. Stuff like flashing a glimpse of Shanks' Abyss arm, or playing a heartbeat sound when Luffy eats the Gum-Gum fruit.

今の破綻にあわせるために始めるんだろ。 シャンクスの左腕のアビスをチラ見せとか、ゴムゴムの実を食べた時に鼓動音が流れるとか。

Others have just run out of patience with the whole subject.

The second flashpoint is the cast. A full remake of East Blue was, to a lot of fans, the one legitimate excuse to retire an aging voice cast without it looking like a cruel, unceremonious replacement mid-story. Instead, the announcement confirmed the same actors are staying on for the ground-up restart.

@何処にでもいて何処にもいない160 likes
This was literally the perfect, legitimate opportunity to transition to a new voice cast without any awkwardness — and yet they're still keeping the same aging actors. I genuinely don't get it.

せっかく新声優を違和感なく正当な理由で決められるチャンスだったのに、このタイミングですらまだ今の声優にやらせるの意味分からん。

Commenters point to Doraemon's cast refresh as the exception, not the rule, and worry the same trap that hit Dragon Ball Kai is waiting here too.

@yutasuzu8890112 likes
Doraemon pulling off a full cast refresh due to aging VAs was an extremely rare exception. One Piece just doesn't have that discipline.

声優陣の高齢化を案じてメインキャストを一新できたドラえもんが稀有なだけ説

@thk_464100 likes
Sorry to the cast, but I can already see where this goes — just like Dragon Ball Kai, people end up comparing versions and saying the younger performances were better.

声優さんには悪いが こう言うのはDB改と同じく若い頃の方が演技が良かったって比較される未来しか見えない

It gets more pointed once Luffy's own voice actor, Tanaka Mayumi, enters the conversation. Fans had already heard she reportedly turned the role down once before accepting.

@lzu-Izu85 likes
Tanaka Mayumi herself apparently said 'there's anxiety about restarting at this age' — and they're making her do it anyway.

田中真弓さん自身が「この年齢で再スタートするのは不安もある」みたいなコメントしてたな

@atskn587820 likes
Tanaka Mayumi is 71... Restarting a series that's run for almost 30 years, completely from episode one? Is that some kind of Greek mythology punishment?

田中真弓71歳やぞ…30年近く連載した作品を1からやり直すとかギリシャ神話の罰かなにか?

@アークアーク-e2y53 likes
The voice actor herself is already saying, basically, 'please, I'm too old for this.'

声優本人がもう高齢なんだから勘弁してくれって言ってるんだよな

By the end of the thread, the mood has curdled into something closer to gallows humor about the whole premise.

@ハービンジャー1 likes
Can you even call it a 'remake' if the original isn't finished? ...Honestly, in a way, it already is.

終わってない作品の焼き直しってリメイクって呼ぶのか? いや、ある意味終わってたわ。

A remake nobody asked for, of a story nobody's finished telling, made by a cast that's already asking for a break — and the joke writes itself before Netflix even gets the chance to market it.

Read next · One Piece

One Piece's 'Five More Years' Promise Turns 8, and Japan Has Had Enough

At this rate he's going to be a "debut author" forever.

Read this roundup

FAQ

Why are Japanese fans upset about THE ONE PIECE remake?
The core objection is timing: the One Piece manga is still running and unfinished, so commenters see a remake of the beginning as premature. The top comment (441 likes) called it 'a remake of a manga that's literally mid-meltdown and still unfinished.'
What do fans fear will be changed in the remake?
The biggest worry is retroactive foreshadowing — commenters expect Oda to quietly insert new scenes hinting at Luffy's Nika powers into the East Blue arc, even though those scenes weren't part of the original story.
Why is voice actor Tanaka Mayumi part of the controversy?
Tanaka, who has voiced Luffy since 1999 and is now 71, reportedly turned the remake role down once before accepting it. Commenters argued the remake was the ideal moment to transition to a younger cast instead of asking her to restart a saga that already runs past 1,000 episodes.

This is one of 43 Japanese-reaction roundups for One Piece. See them all

Other write-ups where the talk was about craft and music

How we classify this (rankings)

More from Japan